I need an alternative breed to my Yorshire Terrier.

"Bryan" <bryan.459 RemoveThis @pac.bell.net> wrote in message
news:l8aqh.19807$yC5.10669@newssvr27.news.prodigy.net...
>I love my Yorkshire Terrier! I love everything about "him" except for one
>thing.
>
> True to the breed description he is difficult to housebreak. For some
> reason if we leave him in the house without direct supervision, eventually
> he'll poop or pee somewhere. This is why he is an outdoor dog.

I have never heard of a Yorkie being an outdoor dog. Does he get to spend
any time in the house with you? What about the Lab? Why do you have dogs
if they are not your house companions?
 >> Stay informed about: I need an alternative breed to my Yorshire Terrier. 

"diddy" <diddy.TakeThisOut@nospam.diddy.net> wrote in message
news:Xns98B790C33A52Fdanny@216.196.97.142...
> in thread news:l8aqh.19807$yC5.10669@newssvr27.news.prodigy.net: "Bryan"
> <bryan.459.TakeThisOut@pac.bell.net> whittled the following words:
>
>> I love my Yorkshire Terrier! I love everything about "him" except for
>> one thing.
>>
>> True to the breed description he is difficult to housebreak. For some
>> reason if we leave him in the house without direct supervision,
>> eventually he'll poop or pee somewhere. This is why he is an outdoor
>> dog. Not a bad thing. He lives on a redwood deck under a sheltered
>> area with a view of the family room. He hangs out with our black lab
>> (and, yes, the Yorkie is in charge). He has a yard to play in and a
>> couple of dogs next door to say hello to as he pleases.
>>
>> I would love it if I could replace my Yorkie with one that didn't use
>> my home for a bathroom (not something I will tolerate). So my
>> question is, what's the next best breed to a Yorkie that isn't
>> difficult to housebreak?
>>
>> He's getting on in years and the dog breed quiz just got me to
>> thinking along these lines.
>>
>>
>>
>
> What about your Lab? I wouldn't have a dog if it didn't live with "ME".
> If
> it's outside, it's just a yard decoration.
 >> Stay informed about: I need an alternative breed to my Yorshire Terrier. 

"diddy" <diddy.RemoveThis@nospam.diddy.net> wrote in message
news:Xns98B790C33A52Fdanny@216.196.97.142...
> in thread news:l8aqh.19807$yC5.10669@newssvr27.news.prodigy.net: "Bryan"
> <bryan.459.RemoveThis@pac.bell.net> whittled the following words:
>
>> I love my Yorkshire Terrier! I love everything about "him" except for
>> one thing.
>>
>> True to the breed description he is difficult to housebreak.
>
> What about your Lab? I wouldn't have a dog if it didn't live with "ME".
> If
> it's outside, it's just a yard decoration.

I respectfully disagree. My dogs do live with me. They just live outside.
In my opinion, dogs belong outside. If I were a dog I would love a yard to
play in. Birds to watch and chase. Cats to keep an eye on. Noises to bark
at when challenging my territory. Smells to float past my nose. Sounds to
listen to and investigate. A bathroom that doesn't require me getting my
person's attention to access.
 >> Stay informed about: I need an alternative breed to my Yorshire Terrier. 

This message is not archived
 >> Stay informed about: I need an alternative breed to my Yorshire Terrier. 

In article <i_nqh.62427$wP1.52534@newssvr14.news.prodigy.net>,
Bryan <bryan.459 RemoveThis @pac.bell.net> wrote:
>I respectfully disagree. My dogs do live with me. They just live outside.
>In my opinion, dogs belong outside. If I were a dog I would love a yard to
>play in. Birds to watch and chase. Cats to keep an eye on. Noises to bark
>at when challenging my territory. Smells to float past my nose. Sounds to
>listen to and investigate. A bathroom that doesn't require me getting my
>person's attention to access.

Sure - they all do. And then they like to come inside, be
with their people/pack, and get their social *needs* met.

BTW - you're not a dog, so it's probably not going to be
base decisions about your dog's well-being on whatever it is
you think you'd like.

Yard ornament? Definitely. But hey, at least it doesn't
take much effort on your part.
--
Melinda Shore - Software longa, hardware brevis - shore RemoveThis @panix.com

Prouder than ever to be a member of the reality-based community
 >> Stay informed about: I need an alternative breed to my Yorshire Terrier. 

"Margaret" <chowmomREMOVE_THIS.RemoveThis@dicorleto.com> wrote in message
news:EJydnS8cXt_cwjTYnZ2dnUVZ_rKvnZ2d@trueband.net...
>
> "Bryan" <bryan.459.RemoveThis@pac.bell.net> wrote in message
> news:l8aqh.19807$yC5.10669@newssvr27.news.prodigy.net...
>>I love my Yorkshire Terrier! I love everything about "him" except for one
>>thing.
>>
>> True to the breed description he is difficult to housebreak. For some
>> reason if we leave him in the house without direct supervision,
>> eventually he'll poop or pee somewhere. This is why he is an outdoor
>> dog.
>
> I have never heard of a Yorkie being an outdoor dog. Does he get to spend
> any time in the house with you? What about the Lab? Why do you have dogs
> if they are not your house companions?
>
>
>

You silly pet people with your rigid pet rules. They are mine and each
others companions. They are part of my home and part of my life. Their
part of the house is the outdoor part and mine is the indoor part. They
come in whenever they show an interest and I'm able to keep an eye on them
(I really only have to watch the lab).

I have very happy friendly healthy dogs.
 >> Stay informed about: I need an alternative breed to my Yorshire Terrier. 

on Sun, 14 Jan 2007 10:58:59 GMT, "Bryan" <bryan.459.TakeThisOut@pac.bell.net>
wrote:

> You silly pet people with your rigid pet rules. They are mine and
> each others companions. They are part of my home and part of my life.
> Their part of the house is the outdoor part and mine is the indoor
> part. They come in whenever they show an interest and I'm able to
> keep an eye on them (I really only have to watch the lab).
>
> I have very happy friendly healthy dogs.

Why do you even have dogs?

--
Lynne
 >> Stay informed about: I need an alternative breed to my Yorshire Terrier. 

"Bryan" <bryan.459.TakeThisOut@pac.bell.net> wrote in
news:i_nqh.62427$wP1.52534@newssvr14.news.prodigy.net:

> I respectfully disagree. My dogs do live with me. They just
> live outside. In my opinion, dogs belong outside. If I were a
> dog I would love a yard to play in.

You might, or you might find it to be a pretty grim existence,
being isolated from your pack. I can guarantee you that my own dog
is not suited, either physically or mentally, to living outdoors.
But, then, I got a dog because I wanted a *companion* animal, and I
chose a breed of dog that was created specifically for that job.

> Birds to watch and chase. Cats to keep an eye on.

They don't need to *live* outdoors to do those things.

> Noises to bark at when challenging my territory.

I appreciate my neighbors' rights to peace and quiet more than
that. If my dog were barky (she's not), I would not allow her to
remain outdoors. The last thing I'd want is a neighbor to get
irritated with my obnoxiously loud and to take matters into his own
hands. Dogs are often killed or disappeared when they are allowed
to become such a nuisance.

> A bathroom that doesn't require me getting my person's attention
> to access.

If you think taking your dog outside is an undue burden, you could
install a dog door. Personally, I like to keep tabs on my dog's
health, which involves paying attention to her potty habits and
output.

--
Shelly
http://www.cat-sidh.net (the Mother Ship)
http://esther.cat-sidh.net (Letters to Esther)

All things move toward their end, all things move toward their end
On that you can be sure
-- Nick Cave
 >> Stay informed about: I need an alternative breed to my Yorshire Terrier. 

"Bryan" <bryan.459 RemoveThis @pac.bell.net> wrote:
> I respectfully disagree. My dogs do live with me. They just live
> outside.

So, they also live with your neighbors,passersby, and tradesman. Big whup.

> In my opinion, dogs belong outside. If I were a dog I would
> love a yard to play in. Birds to watch and chase.

Neighbors to harass.

> Cats to keep an eye on.

Cats to lose an eye to.
 >> Stay informed about: I need an alternative breed to my Yorshire Terrier. 

"Melinda Shore" <shore.RemoveThis@panix.com> wrote in message
news:eod4vl$70j$1@panix3.panix.com...
> In article <i_nqh.62427$wP1.52534@newssvr14.news.prodigy.net>,
> Sure - they all do. And then they like to come inside, be
> with their people/pack, and get their social *needs* met.
>
> BTW - you're not a dog, so it's probably not going to be
> base decisions about your dog's well-being on whatever it is
> you think you'd like.
>
> Yard ornament? Definitely. But hey, at least it doesn't
> take much effort on your part.
> --
> Melinda Shore - Software longa, hardware brevis - shore.RemoveThis@panix.com
>
> Prouder than ever to be a member of the reality-based community


YAWN!
 >> Stay informed about: I need an alternative breed to my Yorshire Terrier. 

"Shelly" <scouvrette.DeleteThis@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:Xns98B8691F4396Dscouvretteyahoocom@130.133.1.4...
> "Bryan" <bryan.459.DeleteThis@pac.bell.net> wrote in
> news:i_nqh.62427$wP1.52534@newssvr14.news.prodigy.net:
>
>> I respectfully disagree. My dogs do live with me. They just
>> live outside. In my opinion, dogs belong outside. If I were a
>> dog I would love a yard to play in.
>
> You might, or you might find it to be a pretty grim existence,
> being isolated from your pack. I can guarantee you that my own dog
> is not suited, either physically or mentally, to living outdoors.
> But, then, I got a dog because I wanted a *companion* animal, and I
> chose a breed of dog that was created specifically for that job.
>
>> Birds to watch and chase. Cats to keep an eye on.
>
> They don't need to *live* outdoors to do those things.
>
>> Noises to bark at when challenging my territory.
>
> I appreciate my neighbors' rights to peace and quiet more than
> that. If my dog were barky (she's not), I would not allow her to
> remain outdoors. The last thing I'd want is a neighbor to get
> irritated with my obnoxiously loud and to take matters into his own
> hands. Dogs are often killed or disappeared when they are allowed
> to become such a nuisance.
>
>> A bathroom that doesn't require me getting my person's attention
>> to access.
>
> If you think taking your dog outside is an undue burden, you could
> install a dog door. Personally, I like to keep tabs on my dog's
> health, which involves paying attention to her potty habits and
> output.
>
> --
> Shelly

Wow! Pet militants. Can anyone just answer the original freakin' question!
 >> Stay informed about: I need an alternative breed to my Yorshire Terrier. 

On Sun, 14 Jan 2007 20:27:59 GMT, "Bryan" <bryan.459 RemoveThis @pac.bell.net>
wrote:

>
>"Shelly" <scouvrette RemoveThis @yahoo.com> wrote in message
>news:Xns98B8691F4396Dscouvretteyahoocom@130.133.1.4...
>> "Bryan" <bryan.459 RemoveThis @pac.bell.net> wrote in
>> news:i_nqh.62427$wP1.52534@newssvr14.news.prodigy.net:
>>
>>> I respectfully disagree. My dogs do live with me. They just
>>> live outside. In my opinion, dogs belong outside. If I were a
>>> dog I would love a yard to play in.
>>
>> You might, or you might find it to be a pretty grim existence,
>> being isolated from your pack. I can guarantee you that my own dog
>> is not suited, either physically or mentally, to living outdoors.
>> But, then, I got a dog because I wanted a *companion* animal, and I
>> chose a breed of dog that was created specifically for that job.
>>
>>> Birds to watch and chase. Cats to keep an eye on.
>>
>> They don't need to *live* outdoors to do those things.
>>
>>> Noises to bark at when challenging my territory.
>>
>> I appreciate my neighbors' rights to peace and quiet more than
>> that. If my dog were barky (she's not), I would not allow her to
>> remain outdoors. The last thing I'd want is a neighbor to get
>> irritated with my obnoxiously loud and to take matters into his own
>> hands. Dogs are often killed or disappeared when they are allowed
>> to become such a nuisance.
>>
>>> A bathroom that doesn't require me getting my person's attention
>>> to access.
>>
>> If you think taking your dog outside is an undue burden, you could
>> install a dog door. Personally, I like to keep tabs on my dog's
>> health, which involves paying attention to her potty habits and
>> output.
>>
>> --
>> Shelly
>
>Wow! Pet militants. Can anyone just answer the original freakin' question!

Sure. The best dog for you would be a stone or cement dog; they do
very well outdoors and you can find one at a garden store. Any breed
will do.

Mustang Sally
 >> Stay informed about: I need an alternative breed to my Yorshire Terrier. 

"Lynne" <unmonitored.email.DeleteThis@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:17mdnUHMYIKbHTfYnZ2dnUVZ_qjinZ2d@insightbb.com...
> on Sun, 14 Jan 2007 10:58:59 GMT, "Bryan" <bryan.459.DeleteThis@pac.bell.net>
> wrote:
>
>> You silly pet people with your rigid pet rules. They are mine and
>> each others companions. They are part of my home and part of my life.
>> Their part of the house is the outdoor part and mine is the indoor
>> part. They come in whenever they show an interest and I'm able to
>> keep an eye on them (I really only have to watch the lab).
>>
>> I have very happy friendly healthy dogs.
>
> Why do you even have dogs?
>
> --
> Lynne

Seriously, you people are amazing. In a bad way.
 >> Stay informed about: I need an alternative breed to my Yorshire Terrier.