Welcome to PetForumz.com!
FAQFAQ      ProfileProfile    Private MessagesPrivate Messages   Log inLog in

Converting from planted community to Cichlids

 
   Pet Problems (Home) -> Freshwater Aquarium RSS
Next:  please help with aquarium repair advice  
Author Message
Mark Trueman

External


Since: Aug 29, 2003
Posts: 2



(Msg. 1) Posted: Fri Aug 29, 2003 2:03 am
Post subject: Converting from planted community to Cichlids
Archived from groups: rec>aquaria>freshwater>misc (more info?)

Hi group,

Im thinking about converting my 160litre tank from its current state
as a heavily planted aquarium (co2, ferts etc) to a cichlid tank and i
have a few questions. At the moment i know nothing about cichlids but
quite a lot about aquaria in general. (so im not a newbie per se)

1. Nitrates - my tapwater nitrates are around the 40ppm mark (pretty
much standard here in the uk unfortunately). My planted tank has lower
nitrates than the tap water level. With a cichlid tank, i wont be
having many plants at all so this nitrate level will remain at around
40ppm with regular water changes. Is this ok, or will i have to go
back to using a nitrate removal mechanism such as a nitragon. I was
hoping not to have to if possible.

2. My water parameters are as follows
ph 8.2 out of the tap, hardness around 12.5 dKh, nitrates 40ppm. Most
of the harness is calcium, very little magnesium. Is this OK for the
African cichlids.

3. I would like quite a few colourful cichlids. Any recommendations?
Am i right in thinking that there are dwarf cichlids? How big do they
grow? I appreciate that there are more compatibility issues with
cichlids so i would just like some opinions as to what other people
put in their tanks.

4. Will i need extra filtration? I have an Eheim 2215 cannister filter
at the moment. Seems to do alright with my current fishload, but by
removing the plants, will i have to have extra biological filtration?

5. Algae, having a well planted tank, i have no algae problems with
3.5wpg thanks to ferts and co2 etc. With no plants and this lighting
level, i know i will get algae. What should i reduce lighting to in
order to prevent the build up of algae. I was thinking maybe 80 watts
(2wpg) or less.

Im sure i will have more questions, but thanks in advance for any
replies

Cheers

Mark

 >> Stay informed about: Converting from planted community to Cichlids 
Back to top
Login to vote
Mark Trueman

External


Since: Aug 29, 2003
Posts: 5



(Msg. 2) Posted: Fri Aug 29, 2003 6:29 pm
Post subject: Re: Converting from planted community to Cichlids [Login to view extended thread Info.]
Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)

<Chopped original questions and replies>

Thanks netmax, as always, a very detailed response.

Ive come to some kind of decision!! I will probably wait until my co2 tank
runs out (which shouldnt be too long now) and then i am going to convert. I
have a load of pigmy chain swords and e.tenellus as a carpet in my tank
which i think will have to come up, its starting to get a bit straggly
anyway. Ive always liked vals and i have a few red tipped ones that dont
seem to do too well in the lower ph with co2 but used to grow like anything
pre-co2. I will try to keep these and maybe buy some more to get a nice
dense "val jungle" in one area of my tank to help with nitrate absorbtion. I
dont want too much variation in plants; my current setup i have to pull
meters of hygro and bacopa out every week. Takes me ages! (hence the reason
im moving away from densely planted aquaria). Good thing about vals is that
they can just be lopped off at the top. I will also get some floating
plants as you suggested

I really like the look of slate so ive decided to make a real rock
background with some pieces of thin slate (5-6mm) that i found in my garden
while digging it up. Im going to silicone (aquatic silicone or course) it
all together onto a perspex sheet and put it inside the tank. Should look
like a natural stone wall without taking up too much tank space. Will do the
usual washes/tests etc.

I was also thinking that i have the following fish in my tank, which ones
would i need to get rid of and which ones would you recommend keeping? (i
have put an X by the ones i think are not compatible with cichlids)

1 Male betta X
5 Harlequins
4 Neons X
5 Glowlights X
7 Corys (bronze and pepper mix)
3 Siamese algae eaters (genuine ones ) - not sure about these
3 black mollies (one of which is a 3 month old baby) X
2 Sunset platys X
5 amano shrimp X - i think these make tasty food for cichlids?

I have a list of Cichlids that should be OK together in my tank, got it from
a website somewhere and i like it. I will see if they are available locally
over the weekend and may come back with some more questions about them. The
list is

1m 2f Labidochromis (Mbuna) - I especially like the Mamba yellow top
1m 2f Cynotilapia (Dwarf Mbuna)
1m 2f Copadichromis ("Utuka".) like peacocks
small school of dither fish (harlequins probably)
1 or 2 dwarf pl*cs

What do you think??

Thanks again

Mark

 >> Stay informed about: Converting from planted community to Cichlids 
Back to top
Login to vote
NetMax

External


Since: Feb 19, 2006
Posts: 2334



(Msg. 3) Posted: Fri Aug 29, 2003 6:29 pm
Post subject: Re: Converting from planted community to Cichlids [Login to view extended thread Info.]
Archived from groups: per prev. post (more info?)

"Mark Trueman" <marktrueman DeleteThis @NOSPAMdsl.pipex.com> wrote in message
news:3f4f8d7f$0$256$cc9e4d1f@news.dial.pipex.com...
> <Chopped original questions and replies>
>
<snip>

Good plan on the CO2 and plants.

> I was also thinking that i have the following fish in my tank, which
ones
> would i need to get rid of and which ones would you recommend keeping?
(i
> have put an X by the ones i think are not compatible with cichlids)
>
> 1 Male betta X
> 5 Harlequins
> 4 Neons X
> 5 Glowlights X
> 7 Corys (bronze and pepper mix)
> 3 Siamese algae eaters (genuine ones ) - not sure about these
> 3 black mollies (one of which is a 3 month old baby) X
> 2 Sunset platys X
> 5 amano shrimp X - i think these make tasty food for cichlids?

I'd X the rasboras and leave the Mollys & Platys as a continuous source
of live food for the cichlids. These fish are also much more compatable
with the water conditions which will be emerging. I keep Platys in my
120g, and so far the Fronts have been content to leave them alone, but I
suspect the Pictus are benefiting from the Platy fry more than the
cichlids. The SAEs & Corys might find the new water conditions and tank
inhabitants to not be to their liking, ymmv.

> I have a list of Cichlids that should be OK together in my tank, got it
from
> a website somewhere and i like it. I will see if they are available
locally
> over the weekend and may come back with some more questions about them.
The
> list is
>
> 1m 2f Labidochromis (Mbuna) - I especially like the Mamba yellow top
> 1m 2f Cynotilapia (Dwarf Mbuna)
> 1m 2f Copadichromis ("Utuka".) like peacocks
> small school of dither fish (harlequins probably)
> 1 or 2 dwarf pl*cs

Fish combinations are recipes where the ingredients, the portions and the
sequence can all be critical. On the surface I could make some comments
about the size of the Copadichromas, and the disposition of the
Cynotilapia, but you are entering an area which looses some
predictability and is full of surprises. I have no first hand experience
with your combination, so my comments would not carry much credibility.
With some certainty, the water parameters will not be conducive to
Harlequins or even many pl*cos, but the plecs are quite adaptable. Keep
in mind that fish-load greatly influences the chances of success when
doing unusual mixes, so some math on their final sizes might influence
your approach.

cheers
NetMax

> What do you think??
>
> Thanks again
>
> Mark
>
>
 >> Stay informed about: Converting from planted community to Cichlids 
Back to top
Login to vote
Display posts from previous:   
Related Topics:
Community Planning - Please assist - Been busy with reef tanks for a couple years and have forgotten much about the freshwater side and therefore am looking for some advice. I plan to setup a peaceful community tank with some driftwood and some of the easier plants such as java fern, java....

friends to cichlids? - What fish are pretty safe around cichlids? I have aquired a 75 gal. tank this week and have a couple of cichlids in there. what is a good fish to put in there that can hold it's on with them?

Building acrylic tanks - If you're building your own acrylic tank how do you bend the 4 corners? I know I can get various sheets and cement them together, but making that bend and at the right spot? Thanks

R.0. Water - I have been using bottled spring water for my tanks. One LFS suggested I switch to R.O. water and said they sell it or I could get it from a machine at the supermarket. Is this type of water better for them? Can a machine at the supermarket be trusted...

Well the LFS said... - That I can't keep a male betta in with any other fish. I thought I had read somewhere that you could keep them in a community tank, just not with gouramis or other bettas. Who's right? Just as a side note. I finally got my 20g up and running :) Put in...
   Pet Problems (Home) -> Freshwater Aquarium All times are: Pacific Time (US & Canada) (change)
Page 1 of 1

 
You can post new topics in this forum
You can reply to topics in this forum
You can edit your posts in this forum
You can delete your posts in this forum
You can vote in polls in this forum



[ Contact us | Terms of Service/Privacy Policy ]