"Mark Trueman" <marktrueman DeleteThis @NOSPAMdsl.pipex.com> wrote in message
news:3f4f8d7f$0$256$cc9e4d1f@news.dial.pipex.com...
> <Chopped original questions and replies>
>
<snip>
Good plan on the CO2 and plants.
> I was also thinking that i have the following fish in my tank, which
ones
> would i need to get rid of and which ones would you recommend keeping?
(i
> have put an X by the ones i think are not compatible with cichlids)
>
> 1 Male betta X
> 5 Harlequins
> 4 Neons X
> 5 Glowlights X
> 7 Corys (bronze and pepper mix)
> 3 Siamese algae eaters (genuine ones ) - not sure about these
> 3 black mollies (one of which is a 3 month old baby) X
> 2 Sunset platys X
> 5 amano shrimp X - i think these make tasty food for cichlids?
I'd X the rasboras and leave the Mollys & Platys as a continuous source
of live food for the cichlids. These fish are also much more compatable
with the water conditions which will be emerging. I keep Platys in my
120g, and so far the Fronts have been content to leave them alone, but I
suspect the Pictus are benefiting from the Platy fry more than the
cichlids. The SAEs & Corys might find the new water conditions and tank
inhabitants to not be to their liking, ymmv.
> I have a list of Cichlids that should be OK together in my tank, got it
from
> a website somewhere and i like it. I will see if they are available
locally
> over the weekend and may come back with some more questions about them.
The
> list is
>
> 1m 2f Labidochromis (Mbuna) - I especially like the Mamba yellow top
> 1m 2f Cynotilapia (Dwarf Mbuna)
> 1m 2f Copadichromis ("Utuka".) like peacocks
> small school of dither fish (harlequins probably)
> 1 or 2 dwarf pl*cs
Fish combinations are recipes where the ingredients, the portions and the
sequence can all be critical. On the surface I could make some comments
about the size of the Copadichromas, and the disposition of the
Cynotilapia, but you are entering an area which looses some
predictability and is full of surprises. I have no first hand experience
with your combination, so my comments would not carry much credibility.
With some certainty, the water parameters will not be conducive to
Harlequins or even many pl*cos, but the plecs are quite adaptable. Keep
in mind that fish-load greatly influences the chances of success when
doing unusual mixes, so some math on their final sizes might influence
your approach.
cheers
NetMax
> What do you think??
>
> Thanks again
>
> Mark
>
> >> Stay informed about: Converting from planted community to Cichlids